Pixel 5 running android 11 should be able to connect to the AC1750 Wireless Dual Band Gigabit Router and navigate the internet while Pi-Hole blocks and Unbound does whatever it does.
Actual Behaviour:
Pixel 5 is connecting but showing a "No Internet" error.
If you tail the pihole log with pihole -t and launch a browser window or app on the Pixel 5, do you see a burst of activity in the log tail from that device?
Yep! Although it looks like the connectivity issue resolved itself after running pihole -d? (Not actually sure why its working now). I'm still seeing ads on https://msn.com and the banner ads on https://ads-blocker.com/testing/ however on all devices.
I think I've figured out the original issue, so here's a follow up post with some details on that.
During debugging before making this post I ran pihole reconfigure which reset the forwarded DNS back to google's. This is why I think the connection started working. I then reset the DNS to 127.0.0.1#5335 instead of 192.168.x.x#5335 like it was before. I think this is what fixed the original issue. And now I just need to build out my blocklist like jfb mentioned.
Hopefully this is helpful if anyone else runs into this, and thanks jfb for the help!