I have Pi-hole v5.17.1 (docker version), FTL v5.23 and Web Interface v5.20.1. One of my users is using iCloud Private Relay (basically, this it is an Apple's implementation of oDoH (Oblivious DNS over HTTPS), meaning that iDevices are using an Apple's proxy server (relay) to avoid the destination D…

[image] MatejKovacic: Is it possible to create a special group (in PiHole) that will not block iCloud Private Relay (while default settings for default group will perform blocking)? This will be added by https://github.com/pi-hole/FTL/pull/1808 allowing you to put the respective domains on …

You can either have iCloud's relaying or Pi-hole's filtering. Pi-hole is already signaling its clients to switch off iCloud in its presence, providing the recommended answers for the domains by default (so it isn't necessary to manually configure them like you tried to). Pi-hole's behaviour can be…

So if I understand - if I set BLOCK_ICLOUD_PR to false, PiHole filtering will be working for all devices, except iDevices (and iDevices won't complaing about iCloud relay not working)?

[image] MatejKovacic: if I set BLOCK_ICLOUD_PR to false, PiHole filtering will be working for all devices, except iDevices (and iDevices won't complaing about iCloud relay not working) Generally yes. The iDevices will use Pi-hole if you have iCloud Private Relay disabled on an individual dev…

[image] MatejKovacic: So if I understand - if I set BLOCK_ICLOUD_PR to false, PiHole filtering will be working for all devices, except iDevices (and iDevices won't complaing about iCloud relay not working)? Yes. But if this is just about the "SpecificNetwork isn't compatible with iCloud Priv…

Thanks a lot for these clarifications. Is it possible to create a special group (in PiHole) that will not block iCloud Private Relay (while default settings for default group will perform blocking)?

Why would you want to do that? Doesn't disabling BLOCK_ICLOUD_PR already achieve what you want?

Yes, but let's suppose you have two iDevices - for one you would like to enable iCloudPR blocking, for other not. If I understand, BLOCK_ICLOUD_PR works globally, and not per devices.

Pi-hole Userspace

iCloud Private Relay problems

General Customizing Pi-hole

show post in topic

Home
Categories
Guidelines
Terms of Service
Privacy Policy

Powered by Discourse, best viewed with JavaScript enabled